As much as I enjoy watching people use conventional knowledge about genetics and familial lineages (I was a geneticist in my working life after all) to try and figure out where Megumi fits within the hierarchy of the Kitsune family, I must point out the 800 pound gorilla in the room. Megumi is a supernatural being. I am not sure any of us know what that entails with regards to lineage or acquisition of features/powers. It may be possible that all that is required is a mere trace of "kitsune blood" in order to trigger a change should proper conditions present themselves. We don't even know what those proper conditions might be. If one were to use conventional genetics to try and explain her lineage you quickly run into a roadblock. Short of invoking gene mutation, it should be incredibly difficult for Great Grandma to spawn a kitsune that may be functionally superior to herself through mere breeding alone. That is, unless of course somewhere in her past she mated with a true 9-tail. This is why, as much as I find it annoying to admit, we can't use conventional science/knowledge to pin down where Megumi came from.darrin wrote: βThu Oct 15, 2020 1:00 pmI certainly won't claim to not be confused by the details of the relationships. To the best of my abilities to seek aid from search ninja, those details have yet to be revealed, and I'm pretty sure that's deliberate on Fred's part.
When Megumi took Piro and Kimiko to The Fox Hole, there was much forum debate on the relation between (Megumi's?) Grandma the Fox Hole owner / manager and (Yakugashi's) GreatGrandma the Shrine / Clan head.
Unfortunately there were just too many possibilities not ruled out in the comic for that debate to get anywhere. (That's not snark; I freely admit to having contributed more noise than signal myself on that subject.) It's a pretty safe bet (from the conversation in 1490/1491) that "GreatGrandma" is the mother of Mugi's mother. On the other side we don't get much explicit description at all though; Megumi calls the Fox Hole manager "Grandma", and Ashe her "cousin"; but there are lots of relations it would be culturally appropriate for Megumi to call "grandma" (great-aunt?) and vastly more that it would be appropriate to call "cousin" (first, second etc.). (In translation anyway.)
My initial guess was that Shrine GreatGrandma and Fox Hole Grandma are not related by blood, just marriage. That would have allowed for Megumi to be from the "human" side of the family, with Ashe and Mugi being on the "foxy" side. The current reveal would change that to being the "cover story" Megumi believed, with her actually being more closely related to those two than she realized. But no, most of that is still just guesswork, and I'm not betting too heavily on any of those specific details.
[1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Moderators: Invisigoth, chemi
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Note: this also means that whatever was going to happen with Erika and Largo last comic has now already happened. Likewise Piro and Kimiko, and whatever happened with Tohoya wanting to see them.
She could just open the door, see the hotel in flames and just decide the best course of action is to go back to bed and forget about it...
She could just open the door, see the hotel in flames and just decide the best course of action is to go back to bed and forget about it...
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
I'm kind of hoping for a montage of her walking past open doors and seeing the fallout of last night on all involved...Voyager wrote: βThu Oct 15, 2020 6:11 pmNote: this also means that whatever was going to happen with Erika and Largo last comic has now already happened. Likewise Piro and Kimiko, and whatever happened with Tohoya wanting to see them.
She could just open the door, see the hotel in flames and just decide the best course of action is to go back to bed and forget about it...
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
How about a Scooby-Doo chase scene, with everybody running in and out of doors.
Proud owner of kendermouse's 500th post.
Lean and slippered forum loon
Lean and slippered forum loon
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Do you have any idea what effect drawing something like that would have on Fred?
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Thanks for the clarification. I was already wondering whether I had missed something. From the story I had thought Megumi was known to be a fox-girl but hiding it in public. Now, it seems she didn't really know, for whatever reason.darrin wrote: βThu Oct 15, 2020 1:00 pmI certainly won't claim to not be confused by the details of the relationships. To the best of my abilities to seek aid from search ninja, those details have yet to be revealed, and I'm pretty sure that's deliberate on Fred's part.
When Megumi took Piro and Kimiko to The Fox Hole, there was much forum debate on the relation between (Megumi's?) Grandma the Fox Hole owner / manager and (Yakugashi's) GreatGrandma the Shrine / Clan head.
Unfortunately there were just too many possibilities not ruled out in the comic for that debate to get anywhere. (That's not snark; I freely admit to having contributed more noise than signal myself on that subject.) It's a pretty safe bet (from the conversation in 1490/1491) that "GreatGrandma" is the mother of Mugi's mother. On the other side we don't get much explicit description at all though; Megumi calls the Fox Hole manager "Grandma", and Ashe her "cousin"; but there are lots of relations it would be culturally appropriate for Megumi to call "grandma" (great-aunt?) and vastly more that it would be appropriate to call "cousin" (first, second etc.). (In translation anyway.)
My initial guess was that Shrine GreatGrandma and Fox Hole Grandma are not related by blood, just marriage. That would have allowed for Megumi to be from the "human" side of the family, with Ashe and Mugi being on the "foxy" side. The current reveal would change that to being the "cover story" Megumi believed, with her actually being more closely related to those two than she realized. But no, most of that is still just guesswork, and I'm not betting too heavily on any of those specific details.
Maybe, fox-girls sometimes 'manifest' later in life. Probably having the unintended side effects the shrine grandma was talking about.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Not to mention the casual readers and newbies.Invisigoth wrote: βThu Oct 15, 2020 9:52 pmDo you have any idea what effect drawing something like that would have on Fred?
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
My go to theory is that her 8 tail grandmother and perhaps Mugi's mother worked to place some spell or curse on her to prevent her true nature from being perceived by anyone, even herself. It may well have been very dangerous for her to be scampering around as an adorable 9 tailed child who may very well have been scooped up by whatever the nationwide equivalent of the TPCD would be and kept securely pumped full of drugs if not killed outright
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
I'm not doing anything of the sort. The only observation I've made is that Megumi calls Grandma "Grandma", and Ashe "cousin", and that Yakugashi calls Megumi "Aunt Megumi". The only assumption I'm yet willing to commit to (in contrast to personal speculation that I explicitly marked in my post as unimportant guesswork) is that that probably isn't completely meaningless. (The fact that many cultures expect children to refer to non-related adults like friends of the family as "aunt" and "uncle" should be obvious enough not to need stating, and should make it quite clear that "not completely meaningless" still doesn't give much ground yet for sussing out actual relationships. This was precisely my point when I mentioned the previous forum debate on the issue, and how it didn't gain much useful ground.)
Which would be another additional assumption not (yet) explicitly supported in the comic, which would reduce the likelihood of a model incorporating that assumption per Occam.It may be possible that all that is required is a mere trace of "kitsune blood" in order to trigger a change should proper conditions present themselves.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Another possibility is that Megumi's bio father was/is in fact a powerful but statistically much rarer male kitsune who was able to mask his own true nature.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
My focus with regards to your earlier post was your final paragraph. It was pretty clear there that you were trying to offer up a suggestion about narrowing down Megumi's lineage and it appeared to be somewhat based on traditional means of determining lineage. I am not trying to fault you for this attempt. In fact I find it rather fun to see people speculate on this topic. I myself am quite curious about her origins. All I wanted to do was point out that as a supernatural being, there is a real possibility that she isn't bound by the normal rules that govern us "normal" people. To that end, I threw out a notion that was meant merely as an example of what could be in order to let readers know that we may likely be in uncharted territory. It appears that you have taken that slightly out of context and assumed I was actually proposing a definite solution to her origin. I simply haven't a clue as to how she properly fits, with respect to bloodline, into the family hierarchy.darrin wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 11:27 amI'm not doing anything of the sort. The only observation I've made is that Megumi calls Grandma "Grandma", and Ashe "cousin", and that Yakugashi calls Megumi "Aunt Megumi". The only assumption I'm yet willing to commit to (in contrast to personal speculation that I explicitly marked in my post as unimportant guesswork) is that that probably isn't completely meaningless. (The fact that many cultures expect children to refer to non-related adults like friends of the family as "aunt" and "uncle" should be obvious enough not to need stating, and should make it quite clear that "not completely meaningless" still doesn't give much ground yet for sussing out actual relationships. This was precisely my point when I mentioned the previous forum debate on the issue, and how it didn't gain much useful ground.)
Which would be another additional assumption not (yet) explicitly supported in the comic, which would reduce the likelihood of a model incorporating that assumption per Occam.It may be possible that all that is required is a mere trace of "kitsune blood" in order to trigger a change should proper conditions present themselves.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
I find that possibility quite intriguing, Invisigoth. It's as likely a possibility as any other, given the fact that we are dealing with a supernatural being. While it requires bringing a somewhat unknown entity (the mysterious MALE kitsune) into the equation, it does offer a way to use conventional genetics and lineage tracing to explain her existance. I think I will hang my hat on this proposal. It fits nicely into my world view as a geneticist.Invisigoth wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 1:33 pmAnother possibility is that Megumi's bio father was/is in fact a powerful but statistically much rarer male kitsune who was able to mask his own true nature.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
We *are* quite rare indeed. ;>Eraden wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 5:01 pmI find that possibility quite intriguing, Invisigoth. It's as likely a possibility as any other, given the fact that we are dealing with a supernatural being. While it requires bringing a somewhat unknown entity (the mysterious MALE kitsune) into the equation, it does offer a way to use conventional genetics and lineage tracing to explain her existance. I think I will hang my hat on this proposal. It fits nicely into my world view as a geneticist.Invisigoth wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 1:33 pmAnother possibility is that Megumi's bio father was/is in fact a powerful but statistically much rarer male kitsune who was able to mask his own true nature.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Hmm, that's right, we do have an in house male kitsune. Might as well get it straight from the fox's mouth. What's your take on Megumi's lineage, Maldrul?maldrul wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 10:39 pmWe *are* quite rare indeed. ;>Eraden wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 5:01 pmI find that possibility quite intriguing, Invisigoth. It's as likely a possibility as any other, given the fact that we are dealing with a supernatural being. While it requires bringing a somewhat unknown entity (the mysterious MALE kitsune) into the equation, it does offer a way to use conventional genetics and lineage tracing to explain her existance. I think I will hang my hat on this proposal. It fits nicely into my world view as a geneticist.Invisigoth wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 1:33 pmAnother possibility is that Megumi's bio father was/is in fact a powerful but statistically much rarer male kitsune who was able to mask his own true nature.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
And more importantly, where were you that weekend Maldrul????Eraden wrote: βSat Oct 17, 2020 12:25 amHmm, that's right, we do have an in house male kitsune. Might as well get it straight from the fox's mouth. What's your take on Megumi's lineage, Maldrul?maldrul wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 10:39 pmWe *are* quite rare indeed. ;>Eraden wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 5:01 pm
I find that possibility quite intriguing, Invisigoth. It's as likely a possibility as any other, given the fact that we are dealing with a supernatural being. While it requires bringing a somewhat unknown entity (the mysterious MALE kitsune) into the equation, it does offer a way to use conventional genetics and lineage tracing to explain her existance. I think I will hang my hat on this proposal. It fits nicely into my world view as a geneticist.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
The reason you guys are rare is because the aloofness of male kitsune,and females hate a in attentive male.maldrul wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 10:39 pmWe *are* quite rare indeed. ;>Eraden wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 5:01 pmI find that possibility quite intriguing, Invisigoth. It's as likely a possibility as any other, given the fact that we are dealing with a supernatural being. While it requires bringing a somewhat unknown entity (the mysterious MALE kitsune) into the equation, it does offer a way to use conventional genetics and lineage tracing to explain her existance. I think I will hang my hat on this proposal. It fits nicely into my world view as a geneticist.Invisigoth wrote: βFri Oct 16, 2020 1:33 pmAnother possibility is that Megumi's bio father was/is in fact a powerful but statistically much rarer male kitsune who was able to mask his own true nature.
I WAS the Owner of Wolfboys 800th post but SOMEBODY had to go and get a new Forum lol!
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Minor logical quible; it is not yet in evidence that she does not know, merely that it is not public knowledge. We will know more once we see her response to the nine tails.
Also, I'm not sure we've been considering what she actually wants out of life. Just because she is a nine-tail does not mean she has any particular interest in being a hyper-powerful magical figure. I recall one of the smartest guys in the world works as a bouncer. He would sometimes solve physics problems when it caught his fancy, but that really wasn't what he was interested in doing, so he didn't.
Maybe she's a locked nine-tail, or maybe she just doesn't want to deal with that snake pit of politics and is good enough/powerful enough that no-one who knows what she is wants to pull her into it lets they be totally unable to control the aftermath.
We just do don't know, yet...
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
As best I can tell, the Sawatari clan are *all* foxgirls that will breed true and do not marry their "sperm donors". The number of tails that a particular Sawatari girl has at birth is random (although actual kitsune lore states that they all have one tail at birth and grow additional tails for each 100 years of life, but this is Fred's world). The more tails a kitsune has, the more magical power they posses. So Megumi was born with nine tails and all the magical power associated with that. It is just as likely (if not more so) that she hides her "kitsuneness" because of the "monster" stigma associated with it. Yaku had attempted the same, but with only 2 tails, she doesn't have the magic necessary. Megumi OTOH could have mastered the technique at a very early age and is her default on a daily basis. Only when she is very angry or depressed does her facade crumble.
- Yl33 D4 N00b
- Posts: 1044
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
- Location: KY
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
I have to agree with maldrul's assesment. I'd be very surprised if Megs didn't know about her kitsune status.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
This is perfectly internally consistent, but problematic in the larger arena of MT. If they all breed true as catgirls regardless of the male's race, then given the span of a few generations and their luck the catgirls should be a much larger presence in the city if not the outright majority. Given that MT seems to work on well-reasoned internal rules (yay for good game design) this means that elther we're missing something, or that's not how it works. We might be missing something, but we don't know what we don't know, so there's no point in worrying about that option until we get more info. OTOH, speculating on alternatives is fun. While the number of tails is probably random, not all alternatives are equally likely, or nine-tails would be so common that they would again warp the MT world, because they really are that stupidly powerful.maldrul wrote: βSun Oct 18, 2020 3:52 pmAs best I can tell, the Sawatari clan are *all* foxgirls that will breed true and do not marry their "sperm donors". The number of tails that a particular Sawatari girl has at birth is random (although actual kitsune lore states that they all have one tail at birth and grow additional tails for each 100 years of life, but this is Fred's world). The more tails a kitsune has, the more magical power they posses. So Megumi was born with nine tails and all the magical power associated with that. It is just as likely (if not more so) that she hides her "kitsuneness" because of the "monster" stigma associated with it. Yaku had attempted the same, but with only 2 tails, she doesn't have the magic necessary. Megumi OTOH could have mastered the technique at a very early age and is her default on a daily basis. Only when she is very angry or depressed does her facade crumble.
(I wonder if Masamichi has a Fluke Foxgirl detector to go with his MG model?)
From a story standpoint, I think she was unaware of her status simply because it makes her story more powerful. Remember, this is the girl who only really came into her own in the story when she pointed her car at a mech for the sake of her friends. Her knowing about her power at that moment makes it far less appealing as a moment of heroism. As well, if she had known what she was, and could access the power, it seems likely that this specific scene would have been a likely time for her reveal. So if we accept that, then either she didn't know, or couldn't access it. We have no way of knowing which, but again, it's more powerful as a story if she didn't know. So, storytelling being what it is, I think that's the most likely explanation.
Certainly it's the explanation that's the most fun.
==
Largely off topic, but I also don't buy Grandma's story about grafting on another tail to make herself a nine-tail; that way lies madness, or at least civil war. Foxes aren't terribly social animals, but that ability would utterly disrupt the social fabric of the kitsune. No, she was jerking her unruly kid around and probably giving her grandkid a good scare, possibly for a good reason we don't know yet.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
PROTIP: There's a reason that one of Grandmother Eight Tails is mismatched.
Another problem facing the kitsune is that they've suffered from inbreeding in the past so some hybridization with baseline humans has resulted in response to the issues. Human society drove the catgirls extinct in MT and a lot of what was true of "monsters" in the past no longer applies
Another problem facing the kitsune is that they've suffered from inbreeding in the past so some hybridization with baseline humans has resulted in response to the issues. Human society drove the catgirls extinct in MT and a lot of what was true of "monsters" in the past no longer applies
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
On the Sawatari not marrying, that could be a reason for a kitsune deciding to reject power. Not everyone wants to be a permanent bachelor, and what may be normal for us could quite easily be exotic and romantic for someone who, per her culture, has no access to it.
On Grandma's tail grafting, do we know how old she actually is? Since she's a nine tail, she could easily have been an adult during the Age of Warring States, and been an active participant in any of the major civil wars over the last 500-800 years. A *lot* can happen in a millennium. And a lot of culture can change.
That also gives Megumi a bit of a nightmare fuel future, and does explain why the Sawatari clan never marry though...
On Grandma's tail grafting, do we know how old she actually is? Since she's a nine tail, she could easily have been an adult during the Age of Warring States, and been an active participant in any of the major civil wars over the last 500-800 years. A *lot* can happen in a millennium. And a lot of culture can change.
That also gives Megumi a bit of a nightmare fuel future, and does explain why the Sawatari clan never marry though...
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
Yeah, but don't forget we only have the word of crazy cousin Youko to explain why. [1490Invisigoth wrote: βMon Oct 19, 2020 10:19 amPROTIP: There's a reason that one of Grandmother Eight Tails is mismatched.
Not saying it's wrong, but I don't think we can accept it as canon yet.
Proud owner of kendermouse's 500th post.
Lean and slippered forum loon
Lean and slippered forum loon
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 872
- Joined: Sun Jun 04, 2017 7:19 pm
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
That's true Paarfipaarfi wrote: βMon Oct 19, 2020 11:28 amYeah, but don't forget we only have the word of crazy cousin Youko to explain why. [1490Invisigoth wrote: βMon Oct 19, 2020 10:19 amPROTIP: There's a reason that one of Grandmother Eight Tails is mismatched.
Not saying it's wrong, but I don't think we can accept it as canon yet.
Re: [1586] Chapter 13 - Redemption
A small correction: as was noted by several others, Great Grandma is an EIGHT-tailed kitsune. In terms of sheer power or at least potential power, Megumi now dwarfs her. The only thing Great Grandma has over Megumi would be years of experience and if Invisigoth and I are right about Great Grandma having cursed or at least suppressed Megumi, those years of experience might not have given her much wisdom. Hell, for how she's treated Mugi, I would say that she doesn't seem to have learned much wisdom. Never EVER try to alienate family. It WILL come back to bite you in the end. I seem to recall one strip in this comic where we briefly caught a glimse of what seemed to be....regret showing on the face of Great Grandma. Maybe she realizes that the manner in which she has governed the clan is perhaps not the best way to have done it. Now that the Nine-Tail is out of the bag, it may be already too late to mend things. If the next few strips reveal that Megumi did not know she is a Nine-Tail, I would submit that Invisigoth's theory about her situation is still the most likely.Voyager wrote: βMon Oct 19, 2020 10:34 amOn the Sawatari not marrying, that could be a reason for a kitsune deciding to reject power. Not everyone wants to be a permanent bachelor, and what may be normal for us could quite easily be exotic and romantic for someone who, per her culture, has no access to it.
On Grandma's tail grafting, do we know how old she actually is? Since she's a nine tail, she could easily have been an adult during the Age of Warring States, and been an active participant in any of the major civil wars over the last 500-800 years. A *lot* can happen in a millennium. And a lot of culture can change.
That also gives Megumi a bit of a nightmare fuel future, and does explain why the Sawatari clan never marry though...
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 44 guests