l33t hosting - our bandwidth pimps.  these guys r0x0rz
megatokyo - relax, we understand j00 what the hell is going on here?
who are these people?
please buy stuff or kimiko will cry...
rant and rave, tell everyone what you think.
comming soon - MT fan links and other stuff
fredart studios - the process behind the madness

    Closed TopicStart new topicStart Poll

> Celluloid Cave FAQ (AMVs GO IN AMC), Read before posting~
Posted: Apr 30 2006, 06:43 PM
Quote Post

Adachi Powaaaaah
Group Icon

Group: Fake Mods
Posts: 6152
Member No.: 22151
Joined: 19-December 03

Most of the text for this has been shamelessly plagiarized from the AMC FAQ.

Celluloid Cave Rules, Guidelines, & FAQ

In order to see that things run smoothly here, and that conversation is worthwhile for everyone, we have a number of Rules in place. Generally speaking, you must simply treat other posters with respect, present yourself and your opinions intelligently, and and keep up with what is already going on and has gone on around the forum.


This is the newest subforum of the MT forums. For the most part, it's fairly straightforward - movies, TV shows, internet videos, etc. However, there may be some confusion in regard to possible overlap with AMC - anime is on TV, and even shows up in theaters.

Generally speaking, what you want to discuss should probably have appeared (or be appearing) on Western television or in Western theaters - so Spirited Away is a viable topic, as is anything on Adult Swim (yeah, even anime). However, you're probably going to get a better response in AMC if you're discussing anime, so we suggest that you take your thread there. Please check AMC first before posting anything anime-related here - if there's already a thread about it there, we will close your thread here.



As mentioned before, Rules are not suggestions, but rather, as the name indicates, rules. Failure to follow these will result in locked threads, or, potentially, a ban.
  • All FAQ and MT:Central FAQ Rules Apply Here
    Which means no flaming, no site plugging, no spamming, no trolling, no posting of non-work-safe images, no revival of dead-threads, etc. Please see the Megatokyo Forum Rules and the general Forum Help. The Mad Mods thread would also be a necessary read to avoid mod attention / action.

  • Search
    Search for previous threads before posting a topic, especially if it's related to perpetually popular and talked about movies and TV shows, like Snakes on a Plane. Rehashes of old and frequently seen material are not greeted warmly if the poster doesn't have anything new to contribute. Yes, the forum is new right now, but it will (hopefully) develop a decent thread base fairly soon, so this still applies.

  • Bootlegs Are Illegal
    This forum is not a resource for locating bootlegs of movies or TV shows. They are illegal, and any requests for them will be shut down immediately. Obviously, you can talk about the content of things you've seen illegally, but you are not allowed to link torrents and the like.

  • Colored Text and Odd Fonts Are Bad
    Most people find colored text (particularly whole posts in colored text) unpleasant to look at, and in some cases unreadable. Likewise, odd text fonts are not recommended. If you want your posts to readable by all forum goers, simply stick to the default text font, color, and size. People will often completely ignore your posts if you do otherwise.

  • Necromancy is Bad
    Check the date on the thread before replying to it. One of the most hated events on this forum is necromancy - the revival of dead threads. If no new posts have been made for a number of days on a thread, it is dead; no one wants to talk about the topic anymore. This is not a hard and fast rule, but generally, a thread that is more than a week old is considered dead. If you have some truly meaningful input to add (not something like, "it sucks!"), then a revival is okay. Past the one or two week point, if you do want to reopen a discussion on an old thread, the best way to do it is to start a new thread with your new angle on the subject, and include a link to the old thread to indicate that you've already read it. If you don't have anything to contribute to an old topic, don't respond to it.

  • Do Not Post Material That Isn't Worksafe
    These forums should be viewable by people at work. To that end, any material posted here should be work safe. Work safeness is a complicated issue, but generally speaking, if it could fit in a PG-13 movie, it's probably work safe. Nudity is out of the question; however, heavily implied, or near nudity is as well. It's always best to err on the side of caution. If you absolutely must share non-work safe images or videos with members, link to them, and make sure that you note that the link in question is not work safe.

  • Use Spoiler Tags
    If you're discussing a show in a thread that is not specifically designated as having spoilers, use spoiler tags. If you are posting text that gives away or ruins a particular series, denote the spoiler text somehow (e.g. [spoiler][quote][COLOR=gray]text of spoiler[/COLOR][/quote][/spoiler] ). It doesn't matter if the show is a day old or a decade; it's a matter of simple courtesy to other forumites who have not yet seen the show. However, realize that it's hard to discuss the latest episode of something without spoilers, which means that if you're starting a thread on something that you think might contain them, mark it as containing spoilers.

  • Don't Flame, Especially Regarding Taste in Movies/TV.
    As stated in the MTC Rules and FAQ, do not flame other users. If your comments are unnecessarily negative, and do not further discussion, then refrain from making them. Making such comments does not yield worthwhile conversation; typically, it does just the opposite. One flame is often enough to send a whole discussion spiraling off topic. This is especially crucial in regard to arguments over what's good and what isn't - you will have differing preferences with people, but this does not mean you can make a post that simply calls someone a fucking idiot for, say, not liking Battlestar Galactica.

  • Don't Leech Images
    If you feel the need to show us large images from a movie or TV show, please link them. Embedding huge images is a great way to abuse people's bandwidth - bandwidth that they are paying for and you are not.

  • One Thread Per Episode
    Right now, the forum isn't big enough to worry about this, but if we get to the point where one show or another is being discussed in great detail, please don't make more than one thread every time a new episode comes out. Or simply start discussing the episode in the main series thread, if there is one.

As stated earlier, following the rules to the letter will likely keep you out of trouble with the mods, but will not necessarily guarantee that you'll go over well with other forum-goers. In order to help you get a feel for the way the forum works, I offer the following suggestions - not rules.
  • Lurk and Learn
    I cannot stress this one enough. There's no better way to get a feel for the forums and what is and is not accepted here than to hang around for awhile, read posts, and see first hand how things run here. As is often said, academic knowledge (i.e., these Rules & Guidelines) isn't worth nearly as much as practical, first hand knowledge.

  • Use Proper English
    To the best of your ability, use clear English; strive for correct spelling and good grammar. This is, perhaps, the second most important point. Resist the temptation to post using "fanboy Japanese" (mixing words such as "baka" and "kawaii" in with your English text) as well as leet speak (l337 5p34k). It's not going to impress anyone.

  • Tell Us What You Think
    If you want to know what we think about this show or that movie, that's fine, and that's great, but tell us what you think. If you don't have anything to say about the show in question other than that you like it, then don't bother posting. This is a forum for discussion, and the best way to kick off discussion is with your own thoughts.

  • Have Thick Skin
    Don't be offended if someone doesn't like your view on BSG, Lost, or any other show, for that matter. In fact, just don't be offended if someone disagrees with you. Don't allow yourself to be drawn into heated arguments by trolls or flamebaiters. Trolling is not tolerated; if you think someone is trolling, or their attitude otherwise has problems, don't make a scene out of it in a thread - PM a mod.

  • You Don't Know Everything
    It is definitely far from safe to assume (and even less safe to sound like you believe) that you know more about a subject than the rest of the forum; we have some very knowledgeable people here, and superiority isn't a tone that folks are prone to appreciate.

  • Use a Meaningful Subject, Especially Regarding Episode Threads
    When creating a new post, use an informative subject line / title. Too often we get threads with titles like "A question," or "I need help." Please be specific about what you want to talk about; if you don't, you likely won't get many people participating in your thread. If you're creating a thread about the latest episode of something or other, please don't use titles like "This week's whatever" - the following week, people will get confused. At the very least, put the air date in the thread title.

  • Read the Thread Before Replying
    If you fail to do so, you're likely to say something that has already been said in the thread. This makes you sound like you're more interested in talking than having a conversation, which tends to put people off.
Important Threads

Here are some stickied threads that will likely prove useful. There is only one at the moment, but there may be more later.
  • Favorite Movies Thread
    Thread here. This is where you post your favorite movies and find out other people's; please don't recreate this thread in the forum.

This post has been edited by Xellos on Jun 21 2006, 08:00 PM
PMEmail Poster
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

Topic Options   Closed TopicStart new topicStart Poll